The controversy revolves around Miles Silvas dropping only one video part for the entire year but still won the Skater Of The Year accolade, released in December, compared to other pro skaters who unveiled their contributions throughout the year.
Critics argue that the SOTY should go to a skater who consistently delivers throughout the year, pointing to impressive feats like Yuto Horigome's two never-before-done (NBD) tricks.
Despite Horigome's impressive video parts, he fell short of the SOTY title.
Additionally, at 55 years old, the legendary Tony Hawk battled a broken femur and still managed to finish his part, showcasing an unparalleled commitment to skateboarding.
The timing of Silvas' solo release, coupled with the absence of consistent contributions throughout the year, has triggered discontent among skateboarders.
Many question the fairness of awarding the title to someone who concentrated their efforts in the year's final month, traditionally when voters reminisce about the standout performances.
Amid this controversy, Gary Rogers, a respected figure in the skateboarding community, has stepped forward to defend Miles Silvas' SOTY win.
Rogers argues that quality should prevail over quantity and that Silvas' single release speaks volumes about the skater's dedication and creativity and quoted 50 Cent's "Get Rich or Die Tryin" album. "You will be in the die trying part," he said.
While some dissenters, including notable YouTube personality Skater Gifted Hater, accuse Thrasher Magazine of bias and cash-driven decisions, most skateboarders acknowledge Silvas' unique style and the impact of his December release.